Losing Google Traffic to AI? What People Magazine Did Next
Download MP3people magazine video 1 (00:04)
At At the end of October, People Inc., which is the company behind People Magazine, Better Homes and Gardens, and 40 some brands, they laid off 195 people, about 6% of the company. In the same memo, two paragraphs later, they noted that they've added 320 new employees so far in 26. So this isn't really a company shrinking. It's one moving priorities around. And the CEO quotes the vast majority of those affected today are in our
Print and legacy web businesses. Now think about that. He said Legacy Web, the website. Now, the thing that most publishers have spent the last 20 years building, he's saying is now legacy. Today let's go over what people actually cut, what it's building instead. And if you run a publication that's a bit smaller, what parts you can steal. Okay, first, some context. Because 195 sounds like a crisis number, but it's not.
The CEO Neil Vogel's memo, he framed it this way: we're optimizing headcount around our most important projects. So those 320 went somewhere. And one more detail: print revenue in the quarter was about 127 million dollars. Print profit was down 32. Yeah, they still mail about nine or 10 million magazine subscribers. They're not killing print. They're just no longer staffing it like it's the future. And the CFO said,
We need to redeploy resources away from some of the legacy businesses like print and even web. Okay, so even web, why is the website in the legacy column? All right. The answer is because the website has stopped getting visitors, the Google visitor kind. So in 24, Google sent people Inc. 55% of its core web sessions. In 2025, that fell to 34%.
This spring it was twenty-five percent. That's a pretty big drop. And Vogel says we've lost nearly 70% of our Google search traffic over the last few years. And so this is accelerating. It's not leveling off. Okay, so what's the cause? Well, it's AI overviews, Google's own answer box that just shows up on search. Now, now the problem, of course, is that 80 or 90% of searches that people track, the reader gets the answer and
People just never get the click to their website. And this is the part that should make every ad supported publisher, you know, wake up a bit. Digital advertising revenue down 8%. ⁓ the CFO said the drop was directly attributable to the session decline, not the ad market, not the rates. The rates actually went up. Fewer people just showed up on the page. So when people say legacy,
web, what they mean is the business model where Google sends strangers to your article and you show them a banner. And that's the model. That model is what's getting laid off. Okay. So what did people hire 320 people to build? People hired people. Okay. So they have their revenue in essentially two piles. The first pile is the legacy pile where the ad revenue shows up only when somebody visits visits the website.
And they see or click on a banner. Okay, so that's the banner ads. The second pile is really the new and the future revenue pile. And that's when anybody visits the website or not. It's subscriptions, it's licensing deals, it's video sponsors, it's events, all the things that create revenue that they can count on. So the advertising pile, the anonymous advertising pile, that's shrinking. The second pile is growing 15% per year so far. So
The CFO says it'll be half the business next year. Okay. Now all their digital growth came from this second pile of revenue, and the website advertising pile just hasn't grown at all. Okay, so what's their current strategy? Let's look at that. Number one, paid subscriptions. this one's a little crazy. People for 20 years have basically run the biggest free content operation on the internet, launching two paid online subscription products last quarter.
which is people VIP and my recipes. ⁓ six million signups so far, and they're converting them, which is great. The people app, which is interesting. ⁓ checked it out. They're really, really pushing their app on their website, has had they have about a 65 person team behind it. App visits they're finding run about three times longer than a website visit. So the people, this sort of free web company is building a direct logged in.
Paying audience now. Okay, so that's the first one. Second one is licensing. So their licensing deals up to are up to about $53 million. that's up 49% from last year. Now it's about 18% of digital revenue. And that's the AI deals with OpenAI, Meta, and Microsoft, and Apple News. Now they block just about every AI crawler that they can, except for Google. So what they're what are they doing? They're suing Google instead.
Okay, third thing, social video edits as its own product. So they have this massive 50 plus social video series across their brand. So they have one called The Intern. It's a scripted comedy series posted on their TikTok and Instagram accounts and ⁓ did 45 million views in a year and sells to a sponsor by the season. And Vogel called it very lucrative and high margin. Okay.
So that's that's their that's them getting into video. Okay, the fourth item that they're leaning into is selling their audience data, not their page views. So when you read a recipe on all recipes or a retirement article on Investopedia, which they also own, ⁓ people's logging what you're interested in. So not cookies, just what you read, because you're logged into these apps. ⁓ then they bundle those interested.
⁓ those interests into audiences and sell them to advertisers. So that that product is now more than half of its business. Okay. So the CEO says that half its business is now ads that run inside streaming TV apps on smart TVs, not on the websites at all. So that's shifted programmatic off of the website and now into ⁓ streaming TV apps, essentially. And it's because they know who the readers are.
There's also a missed opportunity here that I see on their website. I I looked around. They don't have a free registration setup. And essentially much of their content is just open access. And if they were just to set up a simple registration wall, they could get readers logged in. They could track their behavior on the site. And they would be just an additional and a probably a big pile of registrations that they could sell to advertisers, logged in readers that they're tracking.
what content they're interested in. They can match that up perfectly with their current strategy. Maybe that's coming. Okay. And the fifth thing is events and commerce. Basically they they run affiliate income. They've bought a Gen Z food event series and an influencer network. They they have a show called Sexiest Man Alive, ⁓ which is an old franchise. And the revenue's been up because it runs across the magazine and email and TikTok and YouTube and the app and the VIP subscriptions across really all their platforms. So of these five things, the
Thing you'll notice is that none of them need Google to send a stranger to your web page to get the banner ad to create value. This is all logged in reader experience stuff. All right. So what do you do? Well, you can do a lot of what people is doing now. And that's, you know, change what you measure. ⁓ programmatic ads are are are falling downhill faster and faster. Anonymous page views are just not that valuable anymore.
So you know it's time to look at free registrations, subscriptions, newsletters, membership events, sponsorships, things that you can directly control. Get the email before you get the paid subscription. So I can't say this enough. Get that registration wall up, get the email, build your email list faster. We've seen a 2x to 7x faster email list growth compared to opt-ins or pop-ups. ⁓ and then once you get
Readers registered in, you can give them limited access. You decide how much access they get. They get the newsletter, and you also get a logged in reader. So you get to track exactly what each individual reader is interested in. And then that can be used to sell subscriptions at the right time. It can be taken to advertisers and get them to pay for sponsorships. It'll just drive more traffic from your newsletter back to the site. There's so many benefits to that. All right. So
charging subscriptions, this seems kind of obvious, but People Magazine was the like the biggest free content company in on the internet not that long ago. And now they have two paywall produ products. So okay. Now the other thing you can do is to consider what you start locking, hard locking behind your paywall. So the registration wall gets your foot in the door. You can also set registration wall content to be hard locked against the bots, the AI bots.
But as you build your email list, what generally we find happens over time is you'll build confidence in your audience growth and ⁓ the fact that your, you know, your content is now becoming more and more premium. And what you can do, and what we see publishers doing, is starting to lock down premium content. Right. And you can start with sort of the obvious premium content that you produce that you know is higher value, and that becomes something that's valuable to.
Your paid readers, they're willing to pay for it. And you can just very easily, and what the way we handle it is if something's hard locked, it's just automatically blocks all bots. So you have to be a paid subscriber to get to it. ⁓ and then you can start ramping up as your email list grows, as your registration wall is converting, you can ramp up how much hard locked content that you that you do. Okay. Now blocking Google, the Google bot, which
controls both SEO traffic and AI overviews is kind of the big question right now. Like what do you do with that? And I'd say today, this window we're in, if you're still getting traffic from SEO, keep it going. You have this window of time where Google is still sending your traffic, great. Enjoy it. Get the registration wall in there so you can start converting that random traffic into, you know, known email addresses that are that you're tracking activity on.
If you s if your SEO traffic has literally fallen off a cliff and and you're you're thinking, okay, I got a pretty good email list. I got a my newsletter is is tuned up pretty well, it might be time to just not just shut off all the bots and really focus on your email list you have. You can still keep the registration wall up across all your content, but it's hard locked.
For the bots, you're still getting the email signups and off you go. This really depends on where you are in your journey with audience growth and paid subscriptions, what industry you're in. But this is this is the playbook that we basically hand to all our our customers. And if you wanna see how your publication compares as far as audience growth and paid subscription growth who
about five hundred of our publishers, I would encourage you to go to our scorecard calculator and plug in your numbers and see what's weak, see what's strong in your current setup. And it'll also tell you what to do next. So that means just head over to leakypaywall.com/scorecard and you can just the form is all pre filled. You can just kind of adjust the numbers and and see what comes up. If you have questions, let me know. Good luck.
